United made their first ever visit to the Peninsula Stadium on Saturday afternoon as they went up against in-form Salford City.
The Ammies, with only 22 goals conceded, were a stubborn prospect and they were out there to protect their unbeaten home record.
Jon Mellish and Omari Patrick were into the starting line up for the visitors, with Lewis Alessandra and Ethan Walker stepping onto the bench as the Blues went in search of a return to winning ways.
United had an early chance when Patrick went on a surge, only to have his cross blocked. A long throw came in from Kayode, and that was recycled by Guy and Patrick. Kayode showed for it and his clipped cross found Bennett at the back stick. He had to stretch for the header and it went over the bar.
Salford had the ball in the back of the net on five minutes when a free kick was ony half cleared. It sat up nicely for Coutts, but his celebrations were cut short as a whistle blew for an infringement on Hayden.
Turnbull was then allowed to run from deep for the home side and he made his way through the middle of the park, with options to his right. Towell took over and he chose to shoot from distance. It took a deflection and dipped over the bar.
The Blues went in front on 11 minutes when Anderton did some good work to make space. United had plenty in the box and Mellish contested the delivery. It dropped to the edge of the area and George Tanner made no mistake with a sweetly struck volley that left Hladky with no chance.
It became a tight affair, but Carlisle had to defend a wicked inswinging free kick from Hunter which was angled towards Eastham. Bennett was up smartly to clear, and Riley helped to close things down.
Dickenson sent a real teaser of a set piece in at the other end after Kayode had been hauled to the floor, but it was just too far in front of Bennett and Patrick.
Farman expertly saved twice from the predatory Ian Henderson, but the flag was up on both occasions.
Another tense spell saw the action stay in the middle area of the park, but the Ammies probed and Touray put Gotts on the overlap. His cross flashed across the face of goal and Anderton saw it out.
A through ball from Patrick to Kayode brought Hladky from his area to clear, but he smashed it right at Eastham. It was there to strike as it spun out of the air but the red shirts quickly closed the gap.
Patrick was fouled as the clock ticked towards half time and Guy found Hayden with the free kick from wide. He popped it back towards Bennett but Eastham got in the way.
Tanner started the second half as he'd started the first, with a volley from distance. That came after Patrick had twisted past his man to centre. Guy helped it on its way, but the snapshot sailed over the bar.
The Blues won a corner from nothing when Kayode fed Dickenson on the right. He muscled away from his man, but his cut back was cut out. Guy delivered, and Hladky spilled as a header from Hayden came through bodies. It was recycled, and a second header from Kayode had to be gathered by the stopper.
Salford had a real chance on 51 minutes when Henderson swung a pass through for Lowe from the half way line. He had just Farman to beat but the keeper was equal to the challenge as he spread himself to make a superb stop.
It was a good spell for the hosts and Hunter was disappointed when he drilled a delivery into the area. Farman watched it and he was comfortable with letting it go all the way through, with the advancing strikers back on their heels.
Captain Nick Anderton thundered a long-range rasper just over at the other end, and Henderson put a header at the target from just 10-yards out as the Ammies came on the counter. Farman was in top gear once again as he executed another great save.
A training ground free kick routine saw Riley curl wide from 24-yards, after he'd used Dickenson as a bounce board, and it became end-to-end with the red shirts once more on the attack. A cross from Hunter was cleared and Gotts was quickly smothered.
Gotts did find space moments later but a shot on the spin from 12-yards was always heading wide.
Keeper Paul Farman had to backtrack to tip a Touray free kick over the bar as it hung high, but the equaliser came with just over 10 minutes left to play when Towell went on the break. He was thwarted by the excellent Farman, who somehow stopped the crunching effort, but it spun high and fell kindly for substitute James Wilson. He steadied himself before popping it into the net.
The Ammies threw men forward, and United had crosses to deal with, and a low punt from Gotts somehow made it all the way through a packed area.
Anderton had the home defence worried at the other end with a pass that skipped off the surface, and the away side had loud appeals for a penalty when Kayode appeared to have his shirt tugged when he challenged for a high ball inside the box. The referee said no.
Henderson scuffed wide for the home side deep into time added on, when he got on the end of a nod down from Hunter, but it was honours even at the end of what had been an absorbing battle.
Salford City - Wilson (79)
Carlisle United - Tanner (11)
Salford City - Touray (18), Turnbull (58)
Carlisle United - Bennett (45), Mellish (55)
Salford City - Hladky, Touray (Wilson 75), Lowe, Eastham (c), Hunter, Bernard, Turnbull, Towell (Thomas-Asante 63), Gotts, Coutts, Henderson. Subs - Evans (gk), James, Burgess, Threlkeld, Dieseruvwe.
Carlisle United - Farman, Tanner, Hayden, Bennett, Anderton (c), Riley, Mellish, Guy, Dickenson (Alessandra 69), Kayode, Patrick (Zanzala 64). Subs - Norman (gk), McDonald, Armer, Furman, Toure.
Referee - Kevin Johnson
Assistant Referee 1 - Danny Gratton
Assistant Referee 2 - Joe Clark
Fourth Official - Martin Woods
Attendance - BCD